• 0 Posts
  • 420 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: May 19th, 2024

help-circle
  • The first episode of DISCO put me on the path towards dislike. I thought we were going to get slightly more cinematic trek, with Michelle Yeoh’s Character and Michael Burnham forming some sort of leadership team for mostly contained episodes… Perhaps with show long arcs (like VOY or DS9).

    I had such hopes for that during the opening half of the episode. But I was left waiting for something that never showed up.

    I’d love to see POC women taking their rightful place in ST leadership (because they so often have and do in progressive politics IRL). None the less to say what “get” as the root of Star Trek clearly isn’t what the writers “get” as the root of New Trek.






  • Nah, new star trek doesn’t feel classic enough because it’s too netflixed out. Meaning it doesn’t fit comfortable aesthetics, doesn’t feel self-contained (stand alone episodes). Doesn’t feel in-world, and isn’t set in a likeable section of time in Star Trek lore.

    Most people who don’t like New Star Trek want a TNG, VOY, or DS9 era timeline, featuring a strong actress or actor as the Captain, that’s episodic in nature, and operates as a philosophical defense/testing/statement about the best parts of western progressive/liberal democracy using sci fi as a metaphor or container.

    Star Trek isn’t a place for dark gritty season long arcs that feel like movies that aren’t going anywhere. No, we want philosophical premises, in well lit carpeted spaces, about interesting technology, aliens, and psychology… That years later we realise were subtle commentaries (or even hopeful suggestions) about real world problems.

    Lower Decks is currently the best fit for this.