• 4 Posts
  • 96 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 14th, 2023

help-circle




  • Well, I think if we were to resolve this, we’d need a formal definition of neighborhood, and you make a useful distinction of a neighborhood vs a borough or a town. I suspect sociologists have some useful definitions, but that’s not my field.

    it’s much harder to consider someone an expert or proud local of a “city” they don’t visit 90% of.

    This is a lot more difficult to get behind. People are proud of their cities for a variety of reasons; visiting 90% of it seems like an irrelevant criterion. There’s some truth to the trope of the born-in-NYC native who’s never been to the Statue of Liberty.



  • Hmm… I don’t really disagree, I’m just thinking it through…

    Re. your first point: if neighborhoods are isolated and have little in common, then it doesn’t seem crazy to call them neighborhoods.

    There’s the additional fact that some “neighborhoods” are actually cities: e.g. Long Beach is a city of its own but Westwood is a neighborhood of LA. Malibu and Santa Monica are cities but Venice is a neighborhood of LA. Compton is (famously) a city, but Crenshaw is a neighborhood. But these are all generally thought of as part of LA.

    Re. your second point: I guess it’s similar to someone who lives in Boston or NYC and is more likely to travel to Europe than Alabama, but is still able to say “I love the USA.”